Evaluation
- ID
- 4bb99e8e-f101-493e-88d8-be9182fc0d7f
- Submission ID
- aa268dae-34a0-4521-8099-68fdd16baae3
- Method ID
- 32faee51-7691-4521-8cd1-68e34f7f4c6a
- Status
-
Succeeded
- User
-
siyuanmei
- Challenge
-
SynthRAD2025
- Phase
-
Test Task 1 - MRI
- Algorithm
-
mymri
(Image Version 7790135f-c49c-49a1-bac6-758fbae9f193
)
- Submission created
- Aug. 15, 2025, 4:55 p.m.
- Result created
- Aug. 15, 2025, 4:55 p.m.
- Position on leaderboard
-
4
- Algorithm Description:
-
- Publication/Git:
-
- Comment:
Metrics
{
"results": [
{
"mae": 40.49393283863303,
"DICE": 0.8611622452735901,
"HD95": 4.073652267456055,
"psnr": 33.27915711809277,
"ms_ssim": 0.9675896017531198,
"dvh_photon": 0.027890337998470627,
"dvh_proton": 0.0864641768458533,
"mae_photon": 0.015018908306956291,
"mae_proton": 0.05751628056168556,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.22904904596098,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 66.62671550836443
},
{
"mae": 64.70909730457637,
"DICE": 0.8492732048034668,
"HD95": 4.545915603637695,
"psnr": 30.342538029987157,
"ms_ssim": 0.9655291410314862,
"dvh_photon": 0.004859395272321232,
"dvh_proton": 0.007858625476858014,
"mae_photon": 0.0030753170140087605,
"mae_proton": 0.016767678782343864,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.76766818356269,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 82.29259499311351
},
{
"mae": 68.93426598459902,
"DICE": 0.7422600388526917,
"HD95": 6.055587291717529,
"psnr": 28.972056237182,
"ms_ssim": 0.9155490342493182,
"dvh_photon": 0.04022676206183714,
"dvh_proton": 0.280586014530327,
"mae_photon": 0.01043546013534069,
"mae_proton": 0.0321502760052681,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.99272436247226,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 82.26679089229964
},
{
"mae": 75.95749487673189,
"DICE": 0.7693167924880981,
"HD95": 9.152173042297363,
"psnr": 27.545133602411234,
"ms_ssim": 0.9066492544080993,
"dvh_photon": 0.021924730334882507,
"dvh_proton": 0.47744611546671595,
"mae_photon": 0.013906866312026978,
"mae_proton": 0.06158292666077614,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 98.56976993558789,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 75.30808813827682
},
{
"mae": 36.17127810338727,
"DICE": 0.8166677355766296,
"HD95": 4.386800765991211,
"psnr": 33.25098330878554,
"ms_ssim": 0.9669746733838436,
"dvh_photon": 0.0023126993192063685,
"dvh_proton": 0.6521683573315432,
"mae_photon": 0.0007023292127996683,
"mae_proton": 0.005197007209062576,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.99983780846802,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 98.8218905810704
},
{
"mae": 73.29893171032397,
"DICE": 0.829910933971405,
"HD95": 3.8845319747924805,
"psnr": 28.22576832409572,
"ms_ssim": 0.9135825456166675,
"dvh_photon": 0.006925198118017115,
"dvh_proton": 0.1785731821612523,
"mae_photon": 0.0028180009685456753,
"mae_proton": 0.015771331265568733,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 100.0,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 83.75892532978338
},
{
"mae": 52.2586534512918,
"DICE": 0.7725735306739807,
"HD95": 11.308116912841797,
"psnr": 30.55451642090466,
"ms_ssim": 0.9373682170370935,
"dvh_photon": 0.01706468644604007,
"dvh_proton": 0.08805411441422681,
"mae_photon": 0.005812544375658035,
"mae_proton": 0.05082051083445549,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 98.6402312584726,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 79.04895492940378
},
{
"mae": 63.172204858098425,
"DICE": 0.7752139568328857,
"HD95": 4.2618327140808105,
"psnr": 31.219558000269494,
"ms_ssim": 0.9673172166190085,
"dvh_photon": 0.03873499295895225,
"dvh_proton": 0.49409610969936035,
"mae_photon": 0.011878002434968948,
"mae_proton": 0.05459868907928467,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.99473074085785,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 53.2883602297919
},
{
"mae": 41.88977643093697,
"DICE": 0.7954965233802795,
"HD95": 8.003312110900879,
"psnr": 33.492959533833194,
"ms_ssim": 0.9645154092847209,
"dvh_photon": 0.0062011664794239495,
"dvh_proton": 0.3308314068014903,
"mae_photon": 0.004338931292295456,
"mae_proton": 0.04992128163576126,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.9750899529477,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 66.99335854625957
},
{
"mae": 51.441798295576184,
"DICE": 0.8193181753158569,
"HD95": 3.9413836002349854,
"psnr": 32.072665450459986,
"ms_ssim": 0.966330045102297,
"dvh_photon": 0.01041287298536735,
"dvh_proton": 0.0719307842524336,
"mae_photon": 0.003079687710851431,
"mae_proton": 0.019963549450039864,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.99922745919054,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 76.64735392983226
},
{
"mae": 36.54160174860528,
"DICE": 0.640107274055481,
"HD95": 13.791239738464355,
"psnr": 34.275625218010845,
"ms_ssim": 0.9578515058063455,
"dvh_photon": 0.029721119861763262,
"dvh_proton": 0.5151574406099388,
"mae_photon": 0.00299454340711236,
"mae_proton": 0.014377620071172714,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.83615426596756,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 91.01279312821029
},
{
"mae": 68.00078794025355,
"DICE": 0.8862318992614746,
"HD95": 3.014272928237915,
"psnr": 29.91467416249781,
"ms_ssim": 0.9735276422132771,
"dvh_photon": 2.0081915378834303,
"dvh_proton": 2.0127015967943755,
"mae_photon": 0.003767553949728608,
"mae_proton": 0.010062060318887234,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.8603891919756,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 88.95697349140802
},
{
"mae": 58.257513599547664,
"DICE": 0.7158406376838684,
"HD95": 9.165475845336914,
"psnr": 29.964813576651636,
"ms_ssim": 0.9151504505146132,
"dvh_photon": 0.010789078532360417,
"dvh_proton": 0.013677670359482103,
"mae_photon": 0.00263202260248363,
"mae_proton": 0.012658088468015194,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 98.65775852216466,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 91.32227594719244
},
{
"mae": 66.31109034716474,
"DICE": 0.7059105038642883,
"HD95": 5.628480434417725,
"psnr": 30.51885850479369,
"ms_ssim": 0.946305872259934,
"dvh_photon": 0.02402257622602693,
"dvh_proton": 0.1969169648006654,
"mae_photon": 0.008340318687260151,
"mae_proton": 0.041993264108896255,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.90620920417243,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 60.433822823687485
},
{
"mae": 35.85703024490026,
"DICE": 0.8333063125610352,
"HD95": 4.038182258605957,
"psnr": 35.68924705506949,
"ms_ssim": 0.985475576854122,
"dvh_photon": 0.008166795299828528,
"dvh_proton": 0.05087833203338879,
"mae_photon": 0.004327535163611174,
"mae_proton": 0.015326984226703644,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 100.0,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 82.352372694351
},
{
"mae": 61.51923153131259,
"DICE": 0.8978116512298584,
"HD95": 2.8932106494903564,
"psnr": 29.778753734380658,
"ms_ssim": 0.9720782795017371,
"dvh_photon": 2.0002994107149275,
"dvh_proton": 2.009851692903178,
"mae_photon": 0.002016407670453191,
"mae_proton": 0.008556520566344261,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 100.0,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 83.9797749143696
},
{
"mae": 65.68392695264241,
"DICE": 0.7868611812591553,
"HD95": 3.237299680709839,
"psnr": 30.55222354122265,
"ms_ssim": 0.9605282317294581,
"dvh_photon": 0.006880888425012217,
"dvh_proton": 0.028675120534185077,
"mae_photon": 0.002817187923938036,
"mae_proton": 0.013682493008673191,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 100.0,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 89.53887675952033
},
{
"mae": 58.68085988928134,
"DICE": 0.918394148349762,
"HD95": 2.577254295349121,
"psnr": 30.978097902987138,
"ms_ssim": 0.9846974294175713,
"dvh_photon": 0.0011375557297765028,
"dvh_proton": 0.004243862654809753,
"mae_photon": 0.0018428483745083213,
"mae_proton": 0.007299469318240881,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.08496847929209,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 90.41467998325852
},
{
"mae": 91.5936775574529,
"DICE": 0.7652088403701782,
"HD95": 7.901622295379639,
"psnr": 26.85574666337523,
"ms_ssim": 0.8730255751415363,
"dvh_photon": 0.013895688786513025,
"dvh_proton": 0.021541218387235137,
"mae_photon": 0.009326192550361156,
"mae_proton": 0.010701896622776985,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 86.39131972067533,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 86.82502255989287
},
{
"mae": 94.23695859105034,
"DICE": 0.688144862651825,
"HD95": 7.170902252197266,
"psnr": 26.474658025720792,
"ms_ssim": 0.8824611818945394,
"dvh_photon": 0.04015826057255641,
"dvh_proton": 0.6270361136277713,
"mae_photon": 0.01736576296389103,
"mae_proton": 0.04828972741961479,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.67244343260698,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 61.43011230251888
},
{
"mae": 51.66703656314926,
"DICE": 0.9088590145111084,
"HD95": 2.5737035274505615,
"psnr": 31.398149348685354,
"ms_ssim": 0.9807300575320167,
"dvh_photon": 2.008225921510997,
"dvh_proton": 2.0136742222077593,
"mae_photon": 0.0017064075218513608,
"mae_proton": 0.006902018096297979,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.80847856376054,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 94.4924209922328
},
{
"mae": 54.076160594575086,
"DICE": 0.9188120365142822,
"HD95": 2.7096762657165527,
"psnr": 31.474909306491632,
"ms_ssim": 0.985909399112442,
"dvh_photon": 2.019367916702149,
"dvh_proton": 2.0147575748227142,
"mae_photon": 0.0020188603084534407,
"mae_proton": 0.012389647774398327,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.745440713602,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 88.94604873560836
},
{
"mae": 50.38614451671758,
"DICE": 0.9125645756721497,
"HD95": 2.7958085536956787,
"psnr": 31.897986977601555,
"ms_ssim": 0.97852018462381,
"dvh_photon": 0.012404453254143246,
"dvh_proton": 0.026254742033620892,
"mae_photon": 0.001750555937178433,
"mae_proton": 0.003839246230199933,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 100.0,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 91.40897432202657
},
{
"mae": 106.18089307715236,
"DICE": 0.42404821515083313,
"HD95": 12.791438102722168,
"psnr": 26.297998169874646,
"ms_ssim": 0.8594194708921035,
"dvh_photon": 0.08474231420447727,
"dvh_proton": 0.0882458646377043,
"mae_photon": 0.016647376120090485,
"mae_proton": 0.027681857347488403,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 78.87665536921727,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 72.08617811083846
},
{
"mae": 56.436097344354664,
"DICE": 0.702506422996521,
"HD95": 10.349874496459961,
"psnr": 30.391350328442385,
"ms_ssim": 0.9029962564717797,
"dvh_photon": 0.00667635611231226,
"dvh_proton": 0.023061573309780918,
"mae_photon": 0.0024163327179849148,
"mae_proton": 0.010615605860948563,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.92264358389411,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 85.64144111271564
},
{
"mae": 66.64242087268657,
"DICE": 0.8417374491691589,
"HD95": 3.497736692428589,
"psnr": 31.277113585613915,
"ms_ssim": 0.9565999831917523,
"dvh_photon": 0.03003713304922096,
"dvh_proton": 0.24189939594166737,
"mae_photon": 0.014354015700519085,
"mae_proton": 0.04039820283651352,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.99778089685054,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 69.89935956084172
},
{
"mae": 59.736770969644226,
"DICE": 0.8138003349304199,
"HD95": 4.99644660949707,
"psnr": 30.971894747727152,
"ms_ssim": 0.9480497157025453,
"dvh_photon": 0.01662016124004292,
"dvh_proton": 1.0465829255331505,
"mae_photon": 0.0072949957102537155,
"mae_proton": 0.09193645417690277,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 100.0,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 40.959732214228616
},
{
"mae": 80.6771501837648,
"DICE": 0.645946741104126,
"HD95": 9.958280563354492,
"psnr": 27.63691565328996,
"ms_ssim": 0.8739371601594712,
"dvh_photon": 0.03280543024424384,
"dvh_proton": 0.08325779967537075,
"mae_photon": 0.0054767681285738945,
"mae_proton": 0.028628669679164886,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 98.38871797995796,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 81.35001994967152
},
{
"mae": 115.43412393305556,
"DICE": 0.7253992557525635,
"HD95": 9.21005630493164,
"psnr": 25.212419653266704,
"ms_ssim": 0.8240550614219568,
"dvh_photon": 0.03824656149503842,
"dvh_proton": 0.24275469881628584,
"mae_photon": 0.006550412625074387,
"mae_proton": 0.011523017659783363,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 97.62743290415472,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 86.67490376847408
},
{
"mae": 97.9896808544708,
"DICE": 0.795047402381897,
"HD95": 4.220439434051514,
"psnr": 26.083976647558984,
"ms_ssim": 0.8528810001190074,
"dvh_photon": 0.03271801902499878,
"dvh_proton": 0.1592830583064422,
"mae_photon": 0.0063818772323429585,
"mae_proton": 0.031980205327272415,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 98.16074845843079,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 76.05326761764846
},
{
"mae": 91.28437315469651,
"DICE": 0.7213773131370544,
"HD95": 7.114195346832275,
"psnr": 25.858109690747145,
"ms_ssim": 0.9111398257309967,
"dvh_photon": 0.020721080142855657,
"dvh_proton": 0.047404293865834515,
"mae_photon": 0.009814118966460228,
"mae_proton": 0.0327845960855484,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 98.71698219889367,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 73.67864119817669
},
{
"mae": 110.02198912168114,
"DICE": 0.7681405544281006,
"HD95": 7.143352031707764,
"psnr": 25.254963739377704,
"ms_ssim": 0.8478019711955525,
"dvh_photon": 0.004490484930295307,
"dvh_proton": 0.03937042011630086,
"mae_photon": 0.0020248175133019686,
"mae_proton": 0.011603597551584244,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.9966160483905,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 78.37176001826218
},
{
"mae": 50.0156726919795,
"DICE": 0.7272221446037292,
"HD95": 9.452559471130371,
"psnr": 30.05732577390559,
"ms_ssim": 0.9504135432441414,
"dvh_photon": 0.0018897158485328836,
"dvh_proton": 0.006868714500004947,
"mae_photon": 0.001279879012145102,
"mae_proton": 0.012990191578865051,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.98043970650669,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 95.3468290856224
},
{
"mae": 48.383927530934585,
"DICE": 0.7652187943458557,
"HD95": 5.317363739013672,
"psnr": 29.579509085226313,
"ms_ssim": 0.752507286716199,
"dvh_photon": 0.009734381284643238,
"dvh_proton": 0.008472311203019273,
"mae_photon": 0.0019204573472961783,
"mae_proton": 0.007031503599137068,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.99622594715247,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 98.63730719709909
},
{
"mae": 51.47377384342584,
"DICE": 0.7009310722351074,
"HD95": 5.89456844329834,
"psnr": 31.63726475397196,
"ms_ssim": 0.9472736909394849,
"dvh_photon": 0.007297113518219942,
"dvh_proton": 0.25301649521286274,
"mae_photon": 0.003348510479554534,
"mae_proton": 0.02120209112763405,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.92848065726866,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 86.85957359221969
},
{
"mae": 72.00830266159481,
"DICE": 0.695793867111206,
"HD95": 7.091873645782471,
"psnr": 29.30523843187548,
"ms_ssim": 0.9319062844572382,
"dvh_photon": 0.04835266141864485,
"dvh_proton": 0.23367970966594448,
"mae_photon": 0.017227930948138237,
"mae_proton": 0.07493392378091812,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.43694547660574,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 73.85592941331402
},
{
"mae": 55.98051483878188,
"DICE": 0.912175714969635,
"HD95": 2.624591112136841,
"psnr": 31.47417993724531,
"ms_ssim": 0.9800656642748553,
"dvh_photon": 0.004994974266183335,
"dvh_proton": 0.040063583038757844,
"mae_photon": 0.003540303325280547,
"mae_proton": 0.01047326996922493,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.99806332913721,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 87.95115534949673
},
{
"mae": 101.01191961604972,
"DICE": 0.7077748775482178,
"HD95": 10.64128303527832,
"psnr": 25.524302875590898,
"ms_ssim": 0.8376815146428932,
"dvh_photon": 0.19486358300199663,
"dvh_proton": 0.18122435178256346,
"mae_photon": 0.0136580104008317,
"mae_proton": 0.018098343163728714,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 71.68485347035114,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 81.33201366905182
},
{
"mae": 40.22421808055769,
"DICE": 0.8400852084159851,
"HD95": 3.8203468322753906,
"psnr": 32.0746710207034,
"ms_ssim": 0.94241754101914,
"dvh_photon": 0.01261007838549686,
"dvh_proton": 0.032920249481222325,
"mae_photon": 0.0033887929748743773,
"mae_proton": 0.018199928104877472,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.75411501425924,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 91.28949077940845
},
{
"mae": 60.629986111996416,
"DICE": 0.7764313817024231,
"HD95": 6.004256725311279,
"psnr": 28.572745963574842,
"ms_ssim": 0.8807352241941107,
"dvh_photon": 0.015534154004942052,
"dvh_proton": 0.028257247728354848,
"mae_photon": 0.005274340510368347,
"mae_proton": 0.015932727605104446,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 98.1772735514285,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 89.1899799375836
},
{
"mae": 62.7841840848295,
"DICE": 0.8258915543556213,
"HD95": 5.449185371398926,
"psnr": 31.048614147317828,
"ms_ssim": 0.9405879249417046,
"dvh_photon": 0.010024568483269313,
"dvh_proton": 0.06090149822422728,
"mae_photon": 0.0052892849780619144,
"mae_proton": 0.015247583389282227,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.99291343046657,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 86.65395228047394
},
{
"mae": 59.39166603025466,
"DICE": 0.7987386584281921,
"HD95": 6.716135025024414,
"psnr": 29.602076495059862,
"ms_ssim": 0.9145725017837193,
"dvh_photon": 0.008921899199657057,
"dvh_proton": 0.06964340888278156,
"mae_photon": 0.0025095988530665636,
"mae_proton": 0.0202601570636034,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.19941952708122,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 87.33776381089761
},
{
"mae": 63.23390038718879,
"DICE": 0.9164429306983948,
"HD95": 2.581285238265991,
"psnr": 29.949194061192237,
"ms_ssim": 0.9716414462778589,
"dvh_photon": 0.039858714441453384,
"dvh_proton": 0.026494012695955367,
"mae_photon": 0.0031367375049740076,
"mae_proton": 0.015646129846572876,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 98.95482339516207,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 86.73820944374934
},
{
"mae": 60.44393687517216,
"DICE": 0.8919198513031006,
"HD95": 3.3303210735321045,
"psnr": 31.356052716186284,
"ms_ssim": 0.9736589286499282,
"dvh_photon": 0.004032325552583862,
"dvh_proton": 0.016092433176085646,
"mae_photon": 0.002458095783367753,
"mae_proton": 0.011327890679240227,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.01284125586254,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 86.48445297504799
},
{
"mae": 62.02954689224972,
"DICE": 0.7974631786346436,
"HD95": 4.477466106414795,
"psnr": 29.9799845717719,
"ms_ssim": 0.9459388104334424,
"dvh_photon": 0.003263563007626431,
"dvh_proton": 0.0813769416887902,
"mae_photon": 0.0031250326428562403,
"mae_proton": 0.04271780699491501,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 100.0,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 72.40674989501011
},
{
"mae": 57.70304299347659,
"DICE": 0.6313916444778442,
"HD95": 7.136993408203125,
"psnr": 28.789495275626813,
"ms_ssim": 0.7313828380348035,
"dvh_photon": 2.206960598527915,
"dvh_proton": 2.082113413188631,
"mae_photon": 0.010762005113065243,
"mae_proton": 0.02835284359753132,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 98.09321574830447,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 81.7734773074296
},
{
"mae": 65.59483433993631,
"DICE": 0.6020986437797546,
"HD95": 8.741429328918457,
"psnr": 28.386123217738863,
"ms_ssim": 0.9163727001026581,
"dvh_photon": 0.018104064959522662,
"dvh_proton": 0.0862009482992649,
"mae_photon": 0.003028287785127759,
"mae_proton": 0.015889685600996017,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 98.4302976566008,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 81.37952303739098
},
{
"mae": 85.351020243377,
"DICE": 0.6201332807540894,
"HD95": 11.68293571472168,
"psnr": 25.89911074704675,
"ms_ssim": 0.8087097934256524,
"dvh_photon": 0.0032609621683256295,
"dvh_proton": 0.013433472171461007,
"mae_photon": 0.0021583002526313066,
"mae_proton": 0.012117285281419754,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.67555841692804,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 94.39518630192421
},
{
"mae": 74.07746939911111,
"DICE": 0.8982479572296143,
"HD95": 2.8066320419311523,
"psnr": 27.777901755088934,
"ms_ssim": 0.9585859479432353,
"dvh_photon": 0.0023332814597281748,
"dvh_proton": 0.01850433670405895,
"mae_photon": 0.0022888886742293835,
"mae_proton": 0.008619473315775394,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.42559480809557,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 87.59328102593143
},
{
"mae": 58.39148990077232,
"DICE": 0.9227010011672974,
"HD95": 2.4867043495178223,
"psnr": 30.486000564691707,
"ms_ssim": 0.9761826083483204,
"dvh_photon": 2.008621941162306,
"dvh_proton": 2.023521425680431,
"mae_photon": 0.0015323060797527432,
"mae_proton": 0.008192683570086956,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.68873302965163,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 88.8235930645846
},
{
"mae": 62.50814223665476,
"DICE": 0.860011875629425,
"HD95": 3.1793503761291504,
"psnr": 30.921827684351296,
"ms_ssim": 0.9662404914299411,
"dvh_photon": 0.01117804221838116,
"dvh_proton": 0.08637657838460361,
"mae_photon": 0.0076766666024923325,
"mae_proton": 0.021193314343690872,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 98.81932793250563,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 69.45179622904742
},
{
"mae": 50.34945251031817,
"DICE": 0.9288219809532166,
"HD95": 2.4368398189544678,
"psnr": 31.481483991222284,
"ms_ssim": 0.9830165697635046,
"dvh_photon": 2.0520109504214714,
"dvh_proton": 2.0030589447971847,
"mae_photon": 0.0017075034556910396,
"mae_proton": 0.007209538482129574,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.42651351777825,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 93.88320179471891
},
{
"mae": 59.25247845908912,
"DICE": 0.8344570398330688,
"HD95": 5.361677169799805,
"psnr": 31.794118534114318,
"ms_ssim": 0.9524227684313283,
"dvh_photon": 0.00899935775152804,
"dvh_proton": 0.06205738841597018,
"mae_photon": 0.003915160428732634,
"mae_proton": 0.02373599074780941,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.98247393319734,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 74.55600685982489
},
{
"mae": 35.750071352825366,
"DICE": 0.8783491253852844,
"HD95": 3.857661008834839,
"psnr": 36.3311054137346,
"ms_ssim": 0.9840634661712587,
"dvh_photon": 0.013334336385487415,
"dvh_proton": 0.35412152608279746,
"mae_photon": 0.007703268434852362,
"mae_proton": 0.02082541212439537,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 100.0,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 85.06481942064764
},
{
"mae": 61.15724456795116,
"DICE": 0.8853029608726501,
"HD95": 3.207162618637085,
"psnr": 30.735505836474218,
"ms_ssim": 0.9718175244128802,
"dvh_photon": 0.004383653205441073,
"dvh_proton": 0.029134632729086857,
"mae_photon": 0.0021489032078534365,
"mae_proton": 0.009798279963433743,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.97977863752705,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 90.50722998949091
},
{
"mae": 70.2556793767397,
"DICE": 0.8634891510009766,
"HD95": 3.3249824047088623,
"psnr": 28.473384103317372,
"ms_ssim": 0.9341542836082521,
"dvh_photon": 0.002682137500460826,
"dvh_proton": 0.005649139041295296,
"mae_photon": 0.002133288886398077,
"mae_proton": 0.009558497928082943,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.26575828256648,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 92.26037071011517
},
{
"mae": 74.27962037428904,
"DICE": 0.5944733619689941,
"HD95": 11.351432800292969,
"psnr": 28.906960433197128,
"ms_ssim": 0.9266216384364928,
"dvh_photon": 0.019639880007793084,
"dvh_proton": 0.7952321355871994,
"mae_photon": 0.00919449795037508,
"mae_proton": 0.08440730720758438,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.98288420211856,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 63.59192983408912
},
{
"mae": 126.54600903337143,
"DICE": 0.878461480140686,
"HD95": 4.180303573608398,
"psnr": 23.202918691439997,
"ms_ssim": 0.9103151559895868,
"dvh_photon": 0.043365521061436284,
"dvh_proton": 0.018622400539949093,
"mae_photon": 0.008514875546097755,
"mae_proton": 0.012776232324540615,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 95.28351881293058,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 81.87123558685697
},
{
"mae": 53.14766977029562,
"DICE": 0.9314602613449097,
"HD95": 2.279508590698242,
"psnr": 31.305143437883206,
"ms_ssim": 0.9828832115734873,
"dvh_photon": 2.0024814933687516,
"dvh_proton": 2.0221376161117677,
"mae_photon": 0.002157974522560835,
"mae_proton": 0.008442938327789307,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.96188439586767,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 88.0397224867365
},
{
"mae": 56.02076222375098,
"DICE": 0.9262352585792542,
"HD95": 2.402583599090576,
"psnr": 30.788587431830884,
"ms_ssim": 0.9751218651537994,
"dvh_photon": 2.0089843705468837,
"dvh_proton": 2.0192063529010205,
"mae_photon": 0.0022933981381356716,
"mae_proton": 0.012857446447014809,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.09563705121323,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 88.76893549934883
},
{
"mae": 34.943577697082844,
"DICE": 0.8359495997428894,
"HD95": 3.5564138889312744,
"psnr": 35.10145882353159,
"ms_ssim": 0.9806375596309644,
"dvh_photon": 0.005814987072165297,
"dvh_proton": 0.16140970612198005,
"mae_photon": 0.002108139917254448,
"mae_proton": 0.0070160613395273685,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.98446351547919,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 93.65940307755861
},
{
"mae": 56.56129698304158,
"DICE": 0.6275047063827515,
"HD95": 12.731164932250977,
"psnr": 31.235905421110818,
"ms_ssim": 0.9502521954863304,
"dvh_photon": 0.02230082116798667,
"dvh_proton": 0.7039774080971175,
"mae_photon": 0.006676963530480862,
"mae_proton": 0.055566247552633286,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 100.0,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 54.97287855107107
},
{
"mae": 57.56736005609916,
"DICE": 0.8945338129997253,
"HD95": 2.8062047958374023,
"psnr": 30.833045694961946,
"ms_ssim": 0.976522882619548,
"dvh_photon": 2.0171032273139304,
"dvh_proton": 2.173893587703748,
"mae_photon": 0.006753541063517332,
"mae_proton": 0.03369015455245972,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 100.0,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 72.78303540133193
},
{
"mae": 51.22731683503803,
"DICE": 0.8402038812637329,
"HD95": 5.435059070587158,
"psnr": 31.325895738388265,
"ms_ssim": 0.9387826835552782,
"dvh_photon": 0.019630794501369352,
"dvh_proton": 0.12592680787676414,
"mae_photon": 0.00445308955386281,
"mae_proton": 0.025403283536434174,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.63101449791273,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 88.50736786295408
},
{
"mae": 73.64385453281305,
"DICE": 0.7987897992134094,
"HD95": 4.64517879486084,
"psnr": 27.74017714152719,
"ms_ssim": 0.9012276508465268,
"dvh_photon": 0.08711067324842243,
"dvh_proton": 0.028514933341435723,
"mae_photon": 0.006693786941468716,
"mae_proton": 0.01699245348572731,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 97.84347383442767,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 89.37466387468103
},
{
"mae": 49.168996839260345,
"DICE": 0.9223730564117432,
"HD95": 3.222480058670044,
"psnr": 32.57641640719693,
"ms_ssim": 0.9820314560148148,
"dvh_photon": 0.008986602023195261,
"dvh_proton": 0.0346562189453725,
"mae_photon": 0.0017839997308328748,
"mae_proton": 0.00962594710290432,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.98569612660646,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 94.52979937185906
},
{
"mae": 114.44927032545618,
"DICE": 0.7026116847991943,
"HD95": 8.967550277709961,
"psnr": 25.001419987877092,
"ms_ssim": 0.903108473748665,
"dvh_photon": 0.01137439480858894,
"dvh_proton": 0.01829028525067039,
"mae_photon": 0.0067891268990933895,
"mae_proton": 0.010518808849155903,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 95.83212731508107,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 89.03468894851042
},
{
"mae": 96.13963740508612,
"DICE": 0.8366047143936157,
"HD95": 3.605177640914917,
"psnr": 26.176282133054226,
"ms_ssim": 0.9444153960806868,
"dvh_photon": 0.012054965833445584,
"dvh_proton": 0.021164177922442073,
"mae_photon": 0.007962212897837162,
"mae_proton": 0.018196670338511467,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 96.15209051091718,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 73.65582302540577
},
{
"mae": 64.33633013176217,
"DICE": 0.6637957096099854,
"HD95": 12.362113952636719,
"psnr": 28.74796201834854,
"ms_ssim": 0.8929389911423941,
"dvh_photon": 0.10036892634079686,
"dvh_proton": 0.14570336445864782,
"mae_photon": 0.007832533679902554,
"mae_proton": 0.021992897614836693,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.02011544769093,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 83.13515071847026
},
{
"mae": 68.61458427862225,
"DICE": 0.7563256621360779,
"HD95": 6.217767715454102,
"psnr": 28.296505434534552,
"ms_ssim": 0.8918068017071831,
"dvh_photon": 0.005385117366118911,
"dvh_proton": 0.37721412175107283,
"mae_photon": 0.003549993969500065,
"mae_proton": 0.01571471430361271,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.03729083282745,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 90.88494584086655
},
{
"mae": 109.76498672955309,
"DICE": 0.6126454472541809,
"HD95": 12.081025123596191,
"psnr": 25.35372101260699,
"ms_ssim": 0.8180532794510076,
"dvh_photon": 0.2352204581911526,
"dvh_proton": 0.6335491065828592,
"mae_photon": 0.061017829924821854,
"mae_proton": 0.07703035324811935,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 73.40692343328168,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 29.53034081463009
},
{
"mae": 80.35405988381898,
"DICE": 0.7389470934867859,
"HD95": 7.635124206542969,
"psnr": 26.61392292752455,
"ms_ssim": 0.8596756516422636,
"dvh_photon": 0.004250142652466914,
"dvh_proton": 0.07876222381698592,
"mae_photon": 0.006120820064097643,
"mae_proton": 0.022016111761331558,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.6728155061568,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 84.5952421175495
},
{
"mae": 64.69866230554081,
"DICE": 0.9213088750839233,
"HD95": 2.603553295135498,
"psnr": 29.689463319051693,
"ms_ssim": 0.978192550420937,
"dvh_photon": 0.009160362232146474,
"dvh_proton": 0.018416252621732354,
"mae_photon": 0.0014503876445814967,
"mae_proton": 0.006524478085339069,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.49388352860097,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 94.39365618082182
},
{
"mae": 55.022863595055874,
"DICE": 0.7634410262107849,
"HD95": 4.147359371185303,
"psnr": 32.772441229321274,
"ms_ssim": 0.9670762591983475,
"dvh_photon": 0.018669619323316226,
"dvh_proton": 0.28414435636998725,
"mae_photon": 0.009467204101383686,
"mae_proton": 0.057416025549173355,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.99660284545665,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 58.21063004869767
},
{
"mae": 67.42934000129861,
"DICE": 0.7642374038696289,
"HD95": 5.016685485839844,
"psnr": 28.37582344998154,
"ms_ssim": 0.8904551810450114,
"dvh_photon": 0.013348722148285554,
"dvh_proton": 0.11055353255718897,
"mae_photon": 0.009116152301430702,
"mae_proton": 0.03847552090883255,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 95.85707809079963,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 69.01896782152771
},
{
"mae": 61.491750810871885,
"DICE": 0.8180834650993347,
"HD95": 3.414477825164795,
"psnr": 30.228437838506082,
"ms_ssim": 0.9558433713924259,
"dvh_photon": 0.0055382138308574125,
"dvh_proton": 0.0507510505273703,
"mae_photon": 0.0037395067047327757,
"mae_proton": 0.01365823857486248,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.85161082704617,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 84.70075245996527
},
{
"mae": 57.40638757140483,
"DICE": 0.7885900735855103,
"HD95": 4.61118221282959,
"psnr": 29.23385995792378,
"ms_ssim": 0.896376584607281,
"dvh_photon": 0.01793075718477441,
"dvh_proton": 0.010846470760295789,
"mae_photon": 0.003950742073357105,
"mae_proton": 0.015054414980113506,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 96.65867121503109,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 89.72950904826043
},
{
"mae": 126.11945752555991,
"DICE": 0.3984575569629669,
"HD95": 29.534740447998047,
"psnr": 24.26960543618955,
"ms_ssim": 0.6879784035876347,
"dvh_photon": 0.30524919070501977,
"dvh_proton": 1.5134507490678555,
"mae_photon": 0.16398677229881287,
"mae_proton": 0.13422797620296478,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 32.6392619040096,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 65.93927967957944
},
{
"mae": 46.821037432587154,
"DICE": 0.7831900119781494,
"HD95": 3.751181125640869,
"psnr": 33.45665695578893,
"ms_ssim": 0.9576783862678767,
"dvh_photon": 0.025251501505377846,
"dvh_proton": 0.5730424009635827,
"mae_photon": 0.0108390673995018,
"mae_proton": 0.038581084460020065,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 98.88003730330648,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 77.95496647926588
},
{
"mae": 73.78139867649253,
"DICE": 0.8789507150650024,
"HD95": 3.677133798599243,
"psnr": 29.629226714759014,
"ms_ssim": 0.9564628815796531,
"dvh_photon": 0.01589512022470161,
"dvh_proton": 0.04029990011673328,
"mae_photon": 0.0073389154858887196,
"mae_proton": 0.02297956869006157,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.19722423134135,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 72.64270716343572
},
{
"mae": 70.15641672028846,
"DICE": 0.7969368696212769,
"HD95": 5.1997246742248535,
"psnr": 28.235291991953822,
"ms_ssim": 0.8910784085969702,
"dvh_photon": 0.06018134730266377,
"dvh_proton": 0.021395672995045724,
"mae_photon": 0.005067551974207163,
"mae_proton": 0.019443178549408913,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 98.23389393998518,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 87.28609831029186
},
{
"mae": 83.59037164301095,
"DICE": 0.7141910791397095,
"HD95": 6.892459392547607,
"psnr": 26.748541627169388,
"ms_ssim": 0.864927258758797,
"dvh_photon": 0.05991968517230084,
"dvh_proton": 0.15872344780359032,
"mae_photon": 0.005848076660186052,
"mae_proton": 0.026259159669280052,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.49608781710378,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 77.68194839724386
},
{
"mae": 88.48187662923833,
"DICE": 0.7123507857322693,
"HD95": 4.255424499511719,
"psnr": 27.329527402890218,
"ms_ssim": 0.9361958951280646,
"dvh_photon": 0.006983002105813941,
"dvh_proton": 0.01688607929883035,
"mae_photon": 0.0029401713982224464,
"mae_proton": 0.00972786545753479,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 98.98193527002391,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 89.6629527313354
},
{
"mae": 58.78842643187282,
"DICE": 0.9136836528778076,
"HD95": 2.493222951889038,
"psnr": 30.1612547404036,
"ms_ssim": 0.9687710037868031,
"dvh_photon": 2.018748804976184,
"dvh_proton": 2.0118892431924884,
"mae_photon": 0.00541482912376523,
"mae_proton": 0.007660347502678633,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.64091564014653,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 88.88836607457947
},
{
"mae": 88.59756222254362,
"DICE": 0.83018958568573,
"HD95": 5.966092586517334,
"psnr": 24.801732654453858,
"ms_ssim": 0.731589553061795,
"dvh_photon": 0.002841119165947899,
"dvh_proton": 0.025480023226388933,
"mae_photon": 0.002251594327390194,
"mae_proton": 0.02736586704850197,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.69022923036952,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 88.35018273292515
},
{
"mae": 74.06111925854513,
"DICE": 0.7451906204223633,
"HD95": 10.6561279296875,
"psnr": 28.27523479571838,
"ms_ssim": 0.962109645983593,
"dvh_photon": 0.02319632071054781,
"dvh_proton": 0.0090606261706936,
"mae_photon": 0.005504082888364792,
"mae_proton": 0.012475207448005676,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 97.26396764344344,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 85.00913574899415
},
{
"mae": 102.98619245652337,
"DICE": 0.7495430111885071,
"HD95": 7.00329065322876,
"psnr": 25.22781053671233,
"ms_ssim": 0.8716765643857564,
"dvh_photon": 0.013255413842683007,
"dvh_proton": 0.020630963927471428,
"mae_photon": 0.0043969727121293545,
"mae_proton": 0.01525795180350542,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 98.16197883164726,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 82.77058665806581
},
{
"mae": 47.046237798713406,
"DICE": 0.8336628675460815,
"HD95": 5.506012439727783,
"psnr": 33.432150963268,
"ms_ssim": 0.9742082842243828,
"dvh_photon": 0.012742726338217786,
"dvh_proton": 0.14330676523903269,
"mae_photon": 0.003123788395896554,
"mae_proton": 0.02667412720620632,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 100.0,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 70.82978118783745
},
{
"mae": 70.25632913600596,
"DICE": 0.8128902912139893,
"HD95": 3.377474069595337,
"psnr": 29.76802877572908,
"ms_ssim": 0.9480556511913604,
"dvh_photon": 0.04121424148687213,
"dvh_proton": 0.0246424273134563,
"mae_photon": 0.004401881247758865,
"mae_proton": 0.012451861053705215,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.93198574421199,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 85.62409456783561
},
{
"mae": 86.54573949817585,
"DICE": 0.6858896613121033,
"HD95": 5.411874294281006,
"psnr": 26.242440573781654,
"ms_ssim": 0.8496865252908887,
"dvh_photon": 0.003657789705979215,
"dvh_proton": 0.016576204973177303,
"mae_photon": 0.001778705744072795,
"mae_proton": 0.011165617033839226,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 98.49378140142905,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 92.08142539783289
},
{
"mae": 67.02149799706632,
"DICE": 0.8922696709632874,
"HD95": 2.7443525791168213,
"psnr": 29.780097447589625,
"ms_ssim": 0.9698131314218668,
"dvh_photon": 0.014112257160532412,
"dvh_proton": 0.05318068975334727,
"mae_photon": 0.0026007776614278555,
"mae_proton": 0.008806277066469193,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.5987429100709,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 89.23834438325304
},
{
"mae": 146.72143000441315,
"DICE": 0.3719048500061035,
"HD95": 13.539407730102539,
"psnr": 23.274606560346314,
"ms_ssim": 0.7908287987123167,
"dvh_photon": 0.040264257230825974,
"dvh_proton": 0.04090651392372782,
"mae_photon": 0.006561512127518654,
"mae_proton": 0.015308178029954433,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 96.50808868249445,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 81.94368532563638
},
{
"mae": 56.702208717621296,
"DICE": 0.9222400188446045,
"HD95": 2.4623966217041016,
"psnr": 30.711835348855825,
"ms_ssim": 0.9778454653549643,
"dvh_photon": 2.0226707040632594,
"dvh_proton": 2.0161350251289316,
"mae_photon": 0.0017313668504357338,
"mae_proton": 0.009663417004048824,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.38120665402299,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 91.13201763693381
},
{
"mae": 61.01665519330783,
"DICE": 0.920167863368988,
"HD95": 2.4565460681915283,
"psnr": 29.76528436332885,
"ms_ssim": 0.9757596623354766,
"dvh_photon": 2.0261719320159712,
"dvh_proton": 2.0011192332761243,
"mae_photon": 0.001205983106046915,
"mae_proton": 0.006025109905749559,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.17163897252779,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 94.94919561821624
},
{
"mae": 64.17712182397553,
"DICE": 0.8848162889480591,
"HD95": 3.8743233680725098,
"psnr": 29.768258699743203,
"ms_ssim": 0.9667469230151285,
"dvh_photon": 2.0016970623638084,
"dvh_proton": 2.011661268605156,
"mae_photon": 0.0028184344992041588,
"mae_proton": 0.010332725942134857,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.74552378875555,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 93.35836757081753
},
{
"mae": 56.48175264288131,
"DICE": 0.9218774437904358,
"HD95": 2.4530868530273438,
"psnr": 31.021549828104476,
"ms_ssim": 0.9781791353846055,
"dvh_photon": 0.010557814209669843,
"dvh_proton": 0.04424312830940703,
"mae_photon": 0.0036598590668290854,
"mae_proton": 0.019832363352179527,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.99465772726363,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 84.29293852434047
},
{
"mae": 56.80897896419723,
"DICE": 0.9177545309066772,
"HD95": 2.4806320667266846,
"psnr": 31.089513241839008,
"ms_ssim": 0.9816635762683656,
"dvh_photon": 0.006943625086309378,
"dvh_proton": 0.07948509594003206,
"mae_photon": 0.004369096830487251,
"mae_proton": 0.017674949020147324,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 98.47252003159915,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 78.77723089147372
},
{
"mae": 70.02963464601741,
"DICE": 0.765509307384491,
"HD95": 4.949904918670654,
"psnr": 28.735655240141753,
"ms_ssim": 0.9513887406846007,
"dvh_photon": 0.012136184330896084,
"dvh_proton": 0.08888293519431231,
"mae_photon": 0.004727508407086134,
"mae_proton": 0.02239449881017208,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 100.0,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 69.97279200355054
},
{
"mae": 105.43877638839697,
"DICE": 0.789880633354187,
"HD95": 8.29776382446289,
"psnr": 24.790434872292227,
"ms_ssim": 0.9177796368615554,
"dvh_photon": 0.01600897097315523,
"dvh_proton": 0.08220814732783921,
"mae_photon": 0.009527589194476604,
"mae_proton": 0.03234625235199928,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 97.24202429332271,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 61.18445661979889
},
{
"mae": 58.72638413256919,
"DICE": 0.6599996089935303,
"HD95": 7.996039390563965,
"psnr": 31.368228919393943,
"ms_ssim": 0.9528079794664165,
"dvh_photon": 0.018160384555449743,
"dvh_proton": 0.19392678470547176,
"mae_photon": 0.008966504596173763,
"mae_proton": 0.03370904549956322,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.68032318241194,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 74.19680548790389
},
{
"mae": 59.9236114947422,
"DICE": 0.7879759669303894,
"HD95": 3.893864631652832,
"psnr": 30.844593092496147,
"ms_ssim": 0.9634359494508904,
"dvh_photon": 0.018573339795692156,
"dvh_proton": 0.05159090630259439,
"mae_photon": 0.004489058628678322,
"mae_proton": 0.04431063309311867,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 100.0,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 77.18135449908627
},
{
"mae": 71.56018620299074,
"DICE": 0.7618567943572998,
"HD95": 7.557951927185059,
"psnr": 29.0807268266038,
"ms_ssim": 0.9158558329807365,
"dvh_photon": 0.02393791786475502,
"dvh_proton": 0.11934592666063776,
"mae_photon": 0.008371134288609028,
"mae_proton": 0.03441527858376503,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.17273116799427,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 75.57801048469159
},
{
"mae": 50.783428566975246,
"DICE": 0.7629051208496094,
"HD95": 6.679237365722656,
"psnr": 32.661620625036456,
"ms_ssim": 0.9713797316900935,
"dvh_photon": 0.0021287743434487486,
"dvh_proton": 0.022854576788862154,
"mae_photon": 0.004072099458426237,
"mae_proton": 0.028979012742638588,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.99020321334602,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 85.54340820070405
},
{
"mae": 75.8092392824464,
"DICE": 0.7925809621810913,
"HD95": 4.960493087768555,
"psnr": 28.808603468000914,
"ms_ssim": 0.9444362113396331,
"dvh_photon": 0.012809830397491645,
"dvh_proton": 0.10455886829928333,
"mae_photon": 0.010748134925961494,
"mae_proton": 0.023444615304470062,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 100.0,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 50.20346486751587
},
{
"mae": 97.44853983530196,
"DICE": 0.9125899076461792,
"HD95": 3.432455539703369,
"psnr": 25.10426803846542,
"ms_ssim": 0.9322838094897363,
"dvh_photon": 0.052505866156501754,
"dvh_proton": 0.33445016489741003,
"mae_photon": 0.013619025237858295,
"mae_proton": 0.05901126563549042,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 96.29688411199776,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 56.95615824499214
},
{
"mae": 126.9002611126098,
"DICE": 0.632405161857605,
"HD95": 4.43631649017334,
"psnr": 23.701375258719025,
"ms_ssim": 0.8778643862481492,
"dvh_photon": 0.016662784941090473,
"dvh_proton": 0.049429149900754824,
"mae_photon": 0.006732401438057423,
"mae_proton": 0.011190900579094887,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 96.15957104840693,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 85.82450710273017
},
{
"mae": 45.94165393152034,
"DICE": 0.9233164191246033,
"HD95": 2.625,
"psnr": 32.31766904132093,
"ms_ssim": 0.9842511888506077,
"dvh_photon": 0.002125262210885095,
"dvh_proton": 0.012710604947602861,
"mae_photon": 0.0016086024697870016,
"mae_proton": 0.004537325818091631,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.74070400011297,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 94.6098534407881
},
{
"mae": 58.48314625611215,
"DICE": 0.8968526721000671,
"HD95": 3.0,
"psnr": 30.506085037188395,
"ms_ssim": 0.9747061210122909,
"dvh_photon": 2.0046065953015137,
"dvh_proton": 2.0584517860123985,
"mae_photon": 0.004514915868639946,
"mae_proton": 0.027188468724489212,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.84945090571676,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 80.8394596550147
},
{
"mae": 54.02157939287349,
"DICE": 0.7163182497024536,
"HD95": 13.003154754638672,
"psnr": 31.52606092319544,
"ms_ssim": 0.9611516010589685,
"dvh_photon": 0.004615743312970178,
"dvh_proton": 0.01740522023677339,
"mae_photon": 0.0021397918462753296,
"mae_proton": 0.008673608303070068,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.99637742410702,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 92.0536168245898
},
{
"mae": 52.47677801542177,
"DICE": 0.9283517599105835,
"HD95": 2.493420362472534,
"psnr": 31.659755096783165,
"ms_ssim": 0.9844310262220526,
"dvh_photon": 2.0071945484119413,
"dvh_proton": 2.007128888588597,
"mae_photon": 0.0017263995250687003,
"mae_proton": 0.00816216878592968,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.73883433474607,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 93.60521443334481
},
{
"mae": 56.16765054261009,
"DICE": 0.7095831036567688,
"HD95": 8.300881385803223,
"psnr": 30.49575775415264,
"ms_ssim": 0.8721732662833596,
"dvh_photon": 0.006281652632022376,
"dvh_proton": 0.03581434769109761,
"mae_photon": 0.005104446783661842,
"mae_proton": 0.013572975061833858,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.48539971278123,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 86.40493275842344
},
{
"mae": 49.97923677679627,
"DICE": 0.7534684538841248,
"HD95": 5.4553751945495605,
"psnr": 32.52435139200787,
"ms_ssim": 0.9680312868141768,
"dvh_photon": 0.016369135955964745,
"dvh_proton": 0.44230141929515254,
"mae_photon": 0.011861232109367847,
"mae_proton": 0.03898150101304054,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.67315545571532,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 59.58849457558847
},
{
"mae": 105.66392711238501,
"DICE": 0.8011239767074585,
"HD95": 4.586095333099365,
"psnr": 25.354867390055148,
"ms_ssim": 0.8939614783913916,
"dvh_photon": 0.00709651405749198,
"dvh_proton": 0.03118254803196805,
"mae_photon": 0.003554730908945203,
"mae_proton": 0.011511615477502346,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.06396509369829,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 86.58489467944109
},
{
"mae": 52.464404520960805,
"DICE": 0.8020352721214294,
"HD95": 5.5875444412231445,
"psnr": 32.97250235158849,
"ms_ssim": 0.9707027780935442,
"dvh_photon": 0.021604180555700757,
"dvh_proton": 0.20038363612189145,
"mae_photon": 0.007611396256834269,
"mae_proton": 0.02782711200416088,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 100.0,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 80.16790602213307
},
{
"mae": 59.01173242480278,
"DICE": 0.6674469113349915,
"HD95": 9.015028953552246,
"psnr": 29.627277479511555,
"ms_ssim": 0.91416450007249,
"dvh_photon": 0.014091080171715353,
"dvh_proton": 0.01893954279978765,
"mae_photon": 0.0022731844801455736,
"mae_proton": 0.01590941846370697,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.97197178493016,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 91.28150134048258
},
{
"mae": 63.7822920890468,
"DICE": 0.9032460451126099,
"HD95": 2.803224802017212,
"psnr": 29.47572399320328,
"ms_ssim": 0.9680657433220603,
"dvh_photon": 0.005875657251113664,
"dvh_proton": 0.01894983048631939,
"mae_photon": 0.004116476979106665,
"mae_proton": 0.015142939053475857,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.31062704608411,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 82.49574374172394
},
{
"mae": 82.41951107362264,
"DICE": 0.7386629581451416,
"HD95": 7.697076797485352,
"psnr": 27.479686712049663,
"ms_ssim": 0.8852634552977383,
"dvh_photon": 0.01711599843182373,
"dvh_proton": 0.11275638982885558,
"mae_photon": 0.0018750691087916493,
"mae_proton": 0.005257043056190014,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.49817617497118,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 93.84163436129256
},
{
"mae": 49.466454493952334,
"DICE": 0.8097777962684631,
"HD95": 5.494386672973633,
"psnr": 31.745017983769678,
"ms_ssim": 0.9512259022720471,
"dvh_photon": 0.08464981895913805,
"dvh_proton": 0.17451718389309007,
"mae_photon": 0.007241642568260431,
"mae_proton": 0.02110154926776886,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.9825093283582,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 81.47671407081157
},
{
"mae": 85.85616190153311,
"DICE": 0.7728608250617981,
"HD95": 6.379951000213623,
"psnr": 25.73625528769446,
"ms_ssim": 0.8561587840137487,
"dvh_photon": 0.23972160952822186,
"dvh_proton": 0.054526063035135575,
"mae_photon": 0.016686826944351196,
"mae_proton": 0.0636460930109024,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 91.82378713405278,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 59.963136612402835
},
{
"mae": 73.64830537895902,
"DICE": 0.7570119500160217,
"HD95": 6.870361804962158,
"psnr": 28.92180182839004,
"ms_ssim": 0.9100813975694938,
"dvh_photon": 0.002060623625590559,
"dvh_proton": 0.02690397499009045,
"mae_photon": 0.0018963253824040294,
"mae_proton": 0.006566760130226612,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 98.70720303376355,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 96.25327496434849
},
{
"mae": 59.68427855899879,
"DICE": 0.8150120377540588,
"HD95": 4.46358585357666,
"psnr": 30.56860679579247,
"ms_ssim": 0.9519453600998005,
"dvh_photon": 0.0038077852650932366,
"dvh_proton": 0.01935379388220438,
"mae_photon": 0.0051586744375526905,
"mae_proton": 0.018955718725919724,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.96705824938125,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 87.15457596876908
},
{
"mae": 42.18375326916853,
"DICE": 0.8200430274009705,
"HD95": 3.930224895477295,
"psnr": 34.004365544445385,
"ms_ssim": 0.979473810612296,
"dvh_photon": 0.019472273336808125,
"dvh_proton": 0.5247919044199325,
"mae_photon": 0.011682912707328796,
"mae_proton": 0.051328305155038834,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.82394612322652,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 63.8299144341068
},
{
"mae": 59.78362818375322,
"DICE": 0.8262895345687866,
"HD95": 7.390169143676758,
"psnr": 31.22013411705659,
"ms_ssim": 0.9556620659216231,
"dvh_photon": 0.006802232214830799,
"dvh_proton": 0.05075546282745259,
"mae_photon": 0.004914474207907915,
"mae_proton": 0.02038767747581005,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.98724213158465,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 69.23572804723499
},
{
"mae": 53.47904374899246,
"DICE": 0.9055497050285339,
"HD95": 2.652015209197998,
"psnr": 31.62983095393994,
"ms_ssim": 0.9830582348334814,
"dvh_photon": 2.0165877769740392,
"dvh_proton": 2.035868283030585,
"mae_photon": 0.0028120470233261585,
"mae_proton": 0.013004185631871223,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.87959689038902,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 89.34523600675665
},
{
"mae": 71.42409539476884,
"DICE": 0.7424321174621582,
"HD95": 5.0117950439453125,
"psnr": 28.46916592687611,
"ms_ssim": 0.9096118944469672,
"dvh_photon": 0.018761249996613338,
"dvh_proton": 0.06457331786312177,
"mae_photon": 0.0037797370459884405,
"mae_proton": 0.022704750299453735,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.83295763151142,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 85.05773473539439
},
{
"mae": 54.15781658142848,
"DICE": 0.9016393423080444,
"HD95": 2.990056037902832,
"psnr": 31.147794171416123,
"ms_ssim": 0.9772164528910255,
"dvh_photon": 0.001401958961262733,
"dvh_proton": 0.005635065500118448,
"mae_photon": 0.0010592503240332007,
"mae_proton": 0.0065742009319365025,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.9158754180647,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 94.9022732924902
},
{
"mae": 66.7007647033588,
"DICE": 0.6861891150474548,
"HD95": 6.8784990310668945,
"psnr": 29.63485996593247,
"ms_ssim": 0.9094470766173244,
"dvh_photon": 0.0029066766267210175,
"dvh_proton": 0.013225204012662826,
"mae_photon": 0.0014427254209294915,
"mae_proton": 0.008969472721219063,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.99852850289885,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 95.22481670280565
},
{
"mae": 40.62931472488833,
"DICE": 0.7805753946304321,
"HD95": 6.1239013671875,
"psnr": 33.842969160169496,
"ms_ssim": 0.9728422678237691,
"dvh_photon": 0.034982576571262324,
"dvh_proton": 0.24879660772202264,
"mae_photon": 0.01337265595793724,
"mae_proton": 0.03945731371641159,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 98.39710043011104,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 71.63111660464409
},
{
"mae": 62.21356537272141,
"DICE": 0.77704256772995,
"HD95": 5.073993682861328,
"psnr": 30.917312200643504,
"ms_ssim": 0.9604218199960923,
"dvh_photon": 0.007684682488610486,
"dvh_proton": 0.14628864086648272,
"mae_photon": 0.002438604598864913,
"mae_proton": 0.029704606160521507,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 100.0,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 77.801740737888
},
{
"mae": 100.08725699037603,
"DICE": 0.544574499130249,
"HD95": 17.55924415588379,
"psnr": 26.20762082049181,
"ms_ssim": 0.8475558078719732,
"dvh_photon": 0.06247833152724905,
"dvh_proton": 0.17431291462586893,
"mae_photon": 0.006897973828017712,
"mae_proton": 0.0269506573677063,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.60463363481452,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 77.08825161887141
},
{
"mae": 30.876109936655133,
"DICE": 0.8343536853790283,
"HD95": 7.617619514465332,
"psnr": 36.508098903597286,
"ms_ssim": 0.9844299090987687,
"dvh_photon": 0.033839975636531884,
"dvh_proton": 0.31115322761406816,
"mae_photon": 0.006834174506366253,
"mae_proton": 0.028750240802764893,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.99423170920528,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 84.06733790509392
},
{
"mae": 80.9072098733089,
"DICE": 0.7455631494522095,
"HD95": 5.715236663818359,
"psnr": 27.560546063591293,
"ms_ssim": 0.9542243898758623,
"dvh_photon": 0.03238020894311476,
"dvh_proton": 0.017437059412949846,
"mae_photon": 0.003228945890441537,
"mae_proton": 0.008371807634830475,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 98.35213099928465,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 89.11688631604878
},
{
"mae": 63.281442579070976,
"DICE": 0.5824353694915771,
"HD95": 10.337462425231934,
"psnr": 30.03834615445966,
"ms_ssim": 0.939433530433108,
"dvh_photon": 0.019455600101038566,
"dvh_proton": 0.11833549122815082,
"mae_photon": 0.007085078861564398,
"mae_proton": 0.030594542622566223,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 100.0,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 73.4273179506948
},
{
"mae": 63.944118011876576,
"DICE": 0.7816437482833862,
"HD95": 6.606071472167969,
"psnr": 29.190338304723635,
"ms_ssim": 0.9155410840096483,
"dvh_photon": 0.017769105969784992,
"dvh_proton": 0.052282084295994374,
"mae_photon": 0.0038064869586378336,
"mae_proton": 0.014966465532779694,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.96768165979712,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 86.55310362627435
},
{
"mae": 68.6777198746368,
"DICE": 0.7798378467559814,
"HD95": 5.946460247039795,
"psnr": 28.825204622612233,
"ms_ssim": 0.9029548970832408,
"dvh_photon": 0.015836278471262486,
"dvh_proton": 0.08020923069688136,
"mae_photon": 0.004117518197745085,
"mae_proton": 0.013701251707971096,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.99730800062216,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 81.94376194376194
},
{
"mae": 87.15305164640523,
"DICE": 0.7845014333724976,
"HD95": 5.708842754364014,
"psnr": 26.81888350961456,
"ms_ssim": 0.8854960646370077,
"dvh_photon": 0.01837091803279601,
"dvh_proton": 0.04020427240829805,
"mae_photon": 0.0033335748594254255,
"mae_proton": 0.012733228504657745,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 98.70382372002592,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 90.29276848354021
},
{
"mae": 53.904258175744985,
"DICE": 0.931586742401123,
"HD95": 2.7883386611938477,
"psnr": 31.16801073823302,
"ms_ssim": 0.9803368028537661,
"dvh_photon": 0.0146260923954898,
"dvh_proton": 0.07503113802919045,
"mae_photon": 0.0024641857016831636,
"mae_proton": 0.013492676429450512,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.98513728624079,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 91.80633266225429
},
{
"mae": 109.74220764778819,
"DICE": 0.724634051322937,
"HD95": 11.696624755859375,
"psnr": 24.695828380705432,
"ms_ssim": 0.8312163225176615,
"dvh_photon": 0.11937165176517019,
"dvh_proton": 0.08781212653744828,
"mae_photon": 0.013303386978805065,
"mae_proton": 0.02028041146695614,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 77.38590039020876,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 76.18499245472233
},
{
"mae": 60.392381900198316,
"DICE": 0.9104934334754944,
"HD95": 3.329075813293457,
"psnr": 29.33687113193653,
"ms_ssim": 0.9611062090384195,
"dvh_photon": 0.0534147766738883,
"dvh_proton": 0.017464779706979135,
"mae_photon": 0.00491500087082386,
"mae_proton": 0.01711800880730152,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.88799997018302,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 83.33245853453705
},
{
"mae": 63.4323028230741,
"DICE": 0.7860361337661743,
"HD95": 4.705874443054199,
"psnr": 30.53184328866415,
"ms_ssim": 0.9420686220669497,
"dvh_photon": 0.02493153579621,
"dvh_proton": 0.25570128763586886,
"mae_photon": 0.012369776144623756,
"mae_proton": 0.02608565241098404,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.99501072693708,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 61.90409764603313
},
{
"mae": 56.91894216541522,
"DICE": 0.9236165881156921,
"HD95": 2.599773645401001,
"psnr": 31.6354908756401,
"ms_ssim": 0.9777216066428019,
"dvh_photon": 0.014939750101308345,
"dvh_proton": 0.05012206656904231,
"mae_photon": 0.003913840278983116,
"mae_proton": 0.011932317167520523,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.78607519357955,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 87.85109752102217
},
{
"mae": 50.18401499755283,
"DICE": 0.8871135711669922,
"HD95": 3.0040814876556396,
"psnr": 31.970107982340146,
"ms_ssim": 0.9796555513181295,
"dvh_photon": 0.023280438600508324,
"dvh_proton": 0.06755261514654748,
"mae_photon": 0.005399808753281832,
"mae_proton": 0.017413349822163582,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 100.0,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 86.04367209018372
},
{
"mae": 65.93205042747712,
"DICE": 0.8925674557685852,
"HD95": 3.2651963233947754,
"psnr": 29.537418537948355,
"ms_ssim": 0.9643342679937593,
"dvh_photon": 0.015245574623683615,
"dvh_proton": 0.06218237363713869,
"mae_photon": 0.00593531783670187,
"mae_proton": 0.017792094498872757,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.49105958677555,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 79.17921090160038
},
{
"mae": 90.50897223323719,
"DICE": 0.551975429058075,
"HD95": 10.603985786437988,
"psnr": 26.40655755448352,
"ms_ssim": 0.8732522450013878,
"dvh_photon": 0.022148701066311515,
"dvh_proton": 0.2944372556616801,
"mae_photon": 0.0031928610987961292,
"mae_proton": 0.00614387821406126,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.85389109702781,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 93.12460257160087
},
{
"mae": 85.58027459939129,
"DICE": 0.7232639789581299,
"HD95": 5.545378684997559,
"psnr": 26.778636847739655,
"ms_ssim": 0.8428764562692315,
"dvh_photon": 0.06932455622918335,
"dvh_proton": 0.05651403009908292,
"mae_photon": 0.00693763792514801,
"mae_proton": 0.014871678315103054,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 98.17833424601147,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 86.44844000682244
},
{
"mae": 79.84806037013975,
"DICE": 0.7169410586357117,
"HD95": 7.969121932983398,
"psnr": 27.279965095600097,
"ms_ssim": 0.8672782103653084,
"dvh_photon": 0.0196296877033428,
"dvh_proton": 0.06999184647110243,
"mae_photon": 0.002690237481147051,
"mae_proton": 0.0106857530772686,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.42054741373916,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 89.50364517396429
},
{
"mae": 85.54544767493772,
"DICE": 0.8285971879959106,
"HD95": 3.9835309982299805,
"psnr": 27.80586559516459,
"ms_ssim": 0.9076368111478222,
"dvh_photon": 0.07059200018954812,
"dvh_proton": 1.0659997779211912,
"mae_photon": 0.021333547309041023,
"mae_proton": 0.05558881536126137,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 93.31490977698225,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 47.11715272383783
},
{
"mae": 55.61849881240639,
"DICE": 0.8182451128959656,
"HD95": 4.478165149688721,
"psnr": 31.790680668918018,
"ms_ssim": 0.9601802121918882,
"dvh_photon": 0.12002696047985245,
"dvh_proton": 0.3496590730512315,
"mae_photon": 0.014365850947797298,
"mae_proton": 0.04384799301624298,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.92352426591547,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 65.58202559923825
},
{
"mae": 53.25749795868683,
"DICE": 0.8367928862571716,
"HD95": 4.750056266784668,
"psnr": 30.005555977652815,
"ms_ssim": 0.8684469871309641,
"dvh_photon": 0.0024712515916112615,
"dvh_proton": 0.005854646877239082,
"mae_photon": 0.0018672263249754906,
"mae_proton": 0.007078555878251791,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.58954057714345,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 96.06079404466502
},
{
"mae": 70.20984185330035,
"DICE": 0.6682803630828857,
"HD95": 7.200953483581543,
"psnr": 29.1212959480475,
"ms_ssim": 0.9128517592225313,
"dvh_photon": 0.004628936799773469,
"dvh_proton": 0.10421490689300314,
"mae_photon": 0.0053588091395795345,
"mae_proton": 0.03434617817401886,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.4888830372636,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 85.09596716037055
},
{
"mae": 73.49653429112229,
"DICE": 0.7746126055717468,
"HD95": 7.385293960571289,
"psnr": 27.210774871003046,
"ms_ssim": 0.89833046790257,
"dvh_photon": 0.008340147032344385,
"dvh_proton": 0.07755961730591972,
"mae_photon": 0.006639490835368633,
"mae_proton": 0.0332547165453434,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 98.01830227048785,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 77.53796491558771
},
{
"mae": 47.4737725894168,
"DICE": 0.8398177027702332,
"HD95": 4.667828559875488,
"psnr": 33.67658640713578,
"ms_ssim": 0.9734034121934221,
"dvh_photon": 0.01958714745700649,
"dvh_proton": 26.630216629505643,
"mae_photon": 0.005319546442478895,
"mae_proton": 0.014223643578588963,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.9792023531052,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 83.9777138761886
},
{
"mae": 99.28882046188095,
"DICE": 0.8648114204406738,
"HD95": 4.523725509643555,
"psnr": 24.67193041553818,
"ms_ssim": 0.9185796590941836,
"dvh_photon": 0.008330604670010643,
"dvh_proton": 0.07628602875676355,
"mae_photon": 0.010613651014864445,
"mae_proton": 0.03549696132540703,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 96.39920182264211,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 62.499803045184066
},
{
"mae": 138.78497583072317,
"DICE": 0.5894246101379395,
"HD95": 6.186312675476074,
"psnr": 22.98440756405885,
"ms_ssim": 0.8179886979014381,
"dvh_photon": 0.01566367853569223,
"dvh_proton": 0.032062522733570256,
"mae_photon": 0.006165860220789909,
"mae_proton": 0.007769294548779726,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 93.80419631530313,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 81.31813906151213
},
{
"mae": 55.598254995390086,
"DICE": 0.7818167209625244,
"HD95": 6.291031837463379,
"psnr": 29.991282169560364,
"ms_ssim": 0.9349308436785251,
"dvh_photon": 0.015222298310463329,
"dvh_proton": 0.12345209437619681,
"mae_photon": 0.004373910371214151,
"mae_proton": 0.02335154265165329,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 98.88133178777426,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 86.76462730430137
},
{
"mae": 69.93541312434333,
"DICE": 0.7318341135978699,
"HD95": 6.907436370849609,
"psnr": 28.86511867505582,
"ms_ssim": 0.937448509277233,
"dvh_photon": 0.006609940269139927,
"dvh_proton": 0.1301148576389724,
"mae_photon": 0.0010442426428198814,
"mae_proton": 0.0031145275570452213,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.97470624755685,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 97.27968262964013
},
{
"mae": 84.27557357899957,
"DICE": 0.8893639445304871,
"HD95": 3.222752094268799,
"psnr": 27.609474744390113,
"ms_ssim": 0.9574486817885609,
"dvh_photon": 0.011692130737749915,
"dvh_proton": 0.04623765111012473,
"mae_photon": 0.0034005423076450825,
"mae_proton": 0.007634005509316921,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.14039642208084,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 90.79637279656909
},
{
"mae": 53.48695059477282,
"DICE": 0.707362711429596,
"HD95": 7.1724162101745605,
"psnr": 29.441747990713772,
"ms_ssim": 0.9176812904240896,
"dvh_photon": 0.027169928927320307,
"dvh_proton": 0.012709137638466733,
"mae_photon": 0.006745999213308096,
"mae_proton": 0.03745530918240547,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.07185125443628,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 77.44196583808389
},
{
"mae": 66.080353621889,
"DICE": 0.7575610280036926,
"HD95": 8.761382102966309,
"psnr": 28.300579588430217,
"ms_ssim": 0.9322651257112781,
"dvh_photon": 0.04138604313045213,
"dvh_proton": 0.025460594202316424,
"mae_photon": 0.004424719605594873,
"mae_proton": 0.025247935205698013,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.12900783800286,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 81.88462114007945
},
{
"mae": 56.50386602994418,
"DICE": 0.7498242855072021,
"HD95": 5.770396709442139,
"psnr": 31.824282665338547,
"ms_ssim": 0.9509137604997945,
"dvh_photon": 0.0053465182081455205,
"dvh_proton": 0.06843848674642115,
"mae_photon": 0.004023084882646799,
"mae_proton": 0.019021177664399147,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.99973857849443,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 78.51200419246013
},
{
"mae": 106.563657634195,
"DICE": 0.7197909355163574,
"HD95": 4.6869635581970215,
"psnr": 25.311420374306035,
"ms_ssim": 0.8655780248060575,
"dvh_photon": 0.003848427139024425,
"dvh_proton": 0.03882338265716138,
"mae_photon": 0.003254631767049432,
"mae_proton": 0.010110882110893726,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 98.30390936490987,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 85.76135091591196
},
{
"mae": 100.73553673653325,
"DICE": 0.642045259475708,
"HD95": 8.205025672912598,
"psnr": 25.613192431350285,
"ms_ssim": 0.8337289690575197,
"dvh_photon": 0.05486381266191124,
"dvh_proton": 0.24082255581011963,
"mae_photon": 0.011765629053115845,
"mae_proton": 0.01839747279882431,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 87.5081065101055,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 73.40865989394626
},
{
"mae": 42.42912741797926,
"DICE": 0.7444195747375488,
"HD95": 7.887937068939209,
"psnr": 34.584432627127526,
"ms_ssim": 0.9808130017174459,
"dvh_photon": 0.013083183165863646,
"dvh_proton": 0.09977348654677828,
"mae_photon": 0.008278622291982174,
"mae_proton": 0.031187763437628746,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 100.0,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 75.77820306496746
},
{
"mae": 48.89945963650228,
"DICE": 0.9169469475746155,
"HD95": 3.125,
"psnr": 32.355716906312765,
"ms_ssim": 0.9823053095924031,
"dvh_photon": 0.0018519764223268967,
"dvh_proton": 0.022456696408148326,
"mae_photon": 0.0008939711260609329,
"mae_proton": 0.005289867985993624,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.99775520343843,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 94.21385434251425
},
{
"mae": 67.71439101900134,
"DICE": 0.6173814535140991,
"HD95": 6.557491779327393,
"psnr": 29.409468568733125,
"ms_ssim": 0.9493321489544952,
"dvh_photon": 0.00480066232605771,
"dvh_proton": 0.14225300008192537,
"mae_photon": 0.008806216530501842,
"mae_proton": 0.06610849499702454,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.65903055017733,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 76.82127592211494
},
{
"mae": 44.145235193446986,
"DICE": 0.7449309825897217,
"HD95": 6.1345062255859375,
"psnr": 31.56139785431829,
"ms_ssim": 0.9162647116784165,
"dvh_photon": 0.05021588113625101,
"dvh_proton": 0.2801187697381136,
"mae_photon": 0.03180072456598282,
"mae_proton": 0.03392815217375755,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 87.29801649130793,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 75.28573549057444
},
{
"mae": 85.03384750295797,
"DICE": 0.6911682486534119,
"HD95": 4.358006477355957,
"psnr": 27.61586039172537,
"ms_ssim": 0.9390325615424652,
"dvh_photon": 0.010534472459479529,
"dvh_proton": 0.04783572900335051,
"mae_photon": 0.0026310498360544443,
"mae_proton": 0.0029653620440512896,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.38158302354398,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 94.46789517658809
},
{
"mae": 61.280681135908814,
"DICE": 0.7803211212158203,
"HD95": 6.5524115562438965,
"psnr": 29.70544731909459,
"ms_ssim": 0.9233315413547043,
"dvh_photon": 0.032750781719552535,
"dvh_proton": 0.0024967060195058887,
"mae_photon": 0.004730295389890671,
"mae_proton": 0.011952204629778862,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 97.20829465037781,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 94.10021758959087
},
{
"mae": 56.90200666632892,
"DICE": 0.9186856150627136,
"HD95": 2.7668137550354004,
"psnr": 30.758420907578895,
"ms_ssim": 0.9812088925812263,
"dvh_photon": 0.00773990469414655,
"dvh_proton": 0.057371519401373146,
"mae_photon": 0.0034576868638396263,
"mae_proton": 0.014948212541639805,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.87649043981331,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 87.34341692414553
},
{
"mae": 88.87694923896682,
"DICE": 0.6681016683578491,
"HD95": 13.100327491760254,
"psnr": 27.11187913142101,
"ms_ssim": 0.8784391502290297,
"dvh_photon": 0.05013988529355125,
"dvh_proton": 0.718280186210016,
"mae_photon": 0.00452041532844305,
"mae_proton": 0.005756217986345291,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.94112223246721,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 92.21986805506744
},
{
"mae": 40.91617599936965,
"DICE": 0.9151845574378967,
"HD95": 2.614694118499756,
"psnr": 33.64255224541526,
"ms_ssim": 0.9851387370920291,
"dvh_photon": 0.01563335858613145,
"dvh_proton": 0.08638846742552199,
"mae_photon": 0.005156250670552254,
"mae_proton": 0.01657595857977867,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 100.0,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 85.35183061741954
},
{
"mae": 55.22216601203016,
"DICE": 0.9111106395721436,
"HD95": 2.9443228244781494,
"psnr": 31.24273880035378,
"ms_ssim": 0.9771745428471555,
"dvh_photon": 0.0026177578872313137,
"dvh_proton": 0.030155615145981994,
"mae_photon": 0.002393754431977868,
"mae_proton": 0.01258058287203312,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.58229180371005,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 91.51232765708974
},
{
"mae": 61.823648012412924,
"DICE": 0.830487072467804,
"HD95": 4.105825901031494,
"psnr": 30.563795400824713,
"ms_ssim": 0.947881030171794,
"dvh_photon": 0.01352271273119341,
"dvh_proton": 0.42591318690904173,
"mae_photon": 0.013333790935575962,
"mae_proton": 0.06335008144378662,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.92660428030491,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 63.532922105867165
},
{
"mae": 45.60357449848369,
"DICE": 0.8619424700737,
"HD95": 3.0527303218841553,
"psnr": 33.77673190706604,
"ms_ssim": 0.980825164980696,
"dvh_photon": 0.0028287423268715723,
"dvh_proton": 0.019817896296445963,
"mae_photon": 0.0021881700959056616,
"mae_proton": 0.0132426293566823,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.98866239931974,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 88.35523754204779
},
{
"mae": 41.82203200219629,
"DICE": 0.8763854503631592,
"HD95": 3.22117018699646,
"psnr": 34.69296141956568,
"ms_ssim": 0.9844625678617456,
"dvh_photon": 0.010695965212065275,
"dvh_proton": 0.07473325458579835,
"mae_photon": 0.002789225894957781,
"mae_proton": 0.010845093056559563,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.98893433325978,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 91.16487026098629
},
{
"mae": 75.38747614428131,
"DICE": 0.8216205835342407,
"HD95": 3.6729793548583984,
"psnr": 28.663081234554394,
"ms_ssim": 0.9664432638040612,
"dvh_photon": 2.0188414508234187,
"dvh_proton": 2.0525553859792884,
"mae_photon": 0.004974220879375935,
"mae_proton": 0.016929104924201965,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.00798412774604,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 79.55002063194637
},
{
"mae": 62.806756945017455,
"DICE": 0.730800211429596,
"HD95": 5.60896110534668,
"psnr": 30.423997326345184,
"ms_ssim": 0.9352164715974782,
"dvh_photon": 0.014083072444192447,
"dvh_proton": 0.17040115254586047,
"mae_photon": 0.006333488505333662,
"mae_proton": 0.015394452027976513,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.99748858562165,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 78.74260992607893
},
{
"mae": 61.012311395276875,
"DICE": 0.8516553044319153,
"HD95": 3.788956880569458,
"psnr": 30.018620012415877,
"ms_ssim": 0.9428049939804449,
"dvh_photon": 0.019771784548602636,
"dvh_proton": 0.006076297498899513,
"mae_photon": 0.0029050095472484827,
"mae_proton": 0.013923315331339836,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.51152649691674,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 90.98977369130343
},
{
"mae": 62.04720294725896,
"DICE": 0.6571441292762756,
"HD95": 8.32651138305664,
"psnr": 30.452780635730498,
"ms_ssim": 0.9314390066753659,
"dvh_photon": 0.03378879375161578,
"dvh_proton": 0.08802728394461541,
"mae_photon": 0.015654895454645157,
"mae_proton": 0.044200483709573746,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 97.80148302328607,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 76.35848720007135
},
{
"mae": 90.56310859515082,
"DICE": 0.7241543531417847,
"HD95": 6.227522373199463,
"psnr": 25.777033808850053,
"ms_ssim": 0.8612377652498612,
"dvh_photon": 0.0029928735363599895,
"dvh_proton": 0.015653318935539076,
"mae_photon": 0.006081223487854004,
"mae_proton": 0.013448086567223072,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 96.22879929226443,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 93.26912558241297
},
{
"mae": 101.98008614981696,
"DICE": 0.62202388048172,
"HD95": 5.726513385772705,
"psnr": 25.621417247329266,
"ms_ssim": 0.8841523721480307,
"dvh_photon": 0.012333905382667674,
"dvh_proton": 0.04354865875955387,
"mae_photon": 0.003223383566364646,
"mae_proton": 0.006368554197251797,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.50633738431651,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 90.19467941759927
},
{
"mae": 52.89837980251358,
"DICE": 0.8346755504608154,
"HD95": 3.180264472961426,
"psnr": 31.42607556698505,
"ms_ssim": 0.9777377305015708,
"dvh_photon": 0.004044385666054496,
"dvh_proton": 0.04626391080064364,
"mae_photon": 0.0019037938909605145,
"mae_proton": 0.010693157091736794,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.82919760131465,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 92.21608966897291
},
{
"mae": 55.15661363636806,
"DICE": 0.8089559674263,
"HD95": 3.280804395675659,
"psnr": 31.96633480838934,
"ms_ssim": 0.9720729056896876,
"dvh_photon": 0.004068136736218499,
"dvh_proton": 0.07449093231823266,
"mae_photon": 0.0028989282436668873,
"mae_proton": 0.024401536211371422,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 100.0,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 81.11066958076694
},
{
"mae": 124.8520277885125,
"DICE": 0.8644005060195923,
"HD95": 4.232882499694824,
"psnr": 23.124047814876768,
"ms_ssim": 0.9035893731990298,
"dvh_photon": 0.031347563038987176,
"dvh_proton": 0.10055274316416907,
"mae_photon": 0.01167658343911171,
"mae_proton": 0.04240255802869797,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 97.63125128644651,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 59.573703164321714
},
{
"mae": 79.8706629109385,
"DICE": 0.8121531009674072,
"HD95": 3.8947160243988037,
"psnr": 28.141648571399642,
"ms_ssim": 0.9522326821565174,
"dvh_photon": 0.033556232530089325,
"dvh_proton": 0.04199170584255459,
"mae_photon": 0.006102320272475481,
"mae_proton": 0.015479347668588161,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 96.50078165711308,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 78.09503445780358
},
{
"mae": 60.92725832613977,
"DICE": 0.8894526362419128,
"HD95": 3.1131715774536133,
"psnr": 29.83859626828844,
"ms_ssim": 0.9690977602503689,
"dvh_photon": 0.00294718333637298,
"dvh_proton": 0.012630775823666666,
"mae_photon": 0.0025623731780797243,
"mae_proton": 0.005947612226009369,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.45404488405192,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 90.90935021963602
},
{
"mae": 76.09705216671773,
"DICE": 0.6978701949119568,
"HD95": 12.887654304504395,
"psnr": 28.38373152921166,
"ms_ssim": 0.9052655407205606,
"dvh_photon": 0.003101542466579095,
"dvh_proton": 0.39428181754690883,
"mae_photon": 0.0010672776261344552,
"mae_proton": 0.003619140712544322,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 100.0,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 97.39897639599725
},
{
"mae": 60.11310822233506,
"DICE": 0.8688145279884338,
"HD95": 3.670984983444214,
"psnr": 31.949908328847272,
"ms_ssim": 0.9656318451030852,
"dvh_photon": 0.03264415547659226,
"dvh_proton": 0.4366705908485385,
"mae_photon": 0.01088554598391056,
"mae_proton": 0.04723501577973366,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 100.0,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 57.17891003342201
},
{
"mae": 33.99116088667435,
"DICE": 0.8683254718780518,
"HD95": 3.5268967151641846,
"psnr": 35.63961137173061,
"ms_ssim": 0.9853460732988356,
"dvh_photon": 0.007475170826440922,
"dvh_proton": 0.05379695624651743,
"mae_photon": 0.0039474619552493095,
"mae_proton": 0.019412394613027573,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.97611084567606,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 87.33991318057144
},
{
"mae": 53.48970755017592,
"DICE": 0.8831499814987183,
"HD95": 3.3818490505218506,
"psnr": 31.817759660105324,
"ms_ssim": 0.9799123597131648,
"dvh_photon": 0.0034765831780308853,
"dvh_proton": 0.017621989570170807,
"mae_photon": 0.002503950148820877,
"mae_proton": 0.010920213535428047,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.90311039458689,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 89.37502708793829
},
{
"mae": 128.6239109483199,
"DICE": 0.7927137613296509,
"HD95": 6.791158676147461,
"psnr": 23.627091483569753,
"ms_ssim": 0.8888931876451243,
"dvh_photon": 0.05413095327656606,
"dvh_proton": 0.052761129946855514,
"mae_photon": 0.013490084558725357,
"mae_proton": 0.01670796610414982,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 92.6336949830717,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 73.20559272678774
},
{
"mae": 100.35108697027368,
"DICE": 0.6524375677108765,
"HD95": 7.5728840827941895,
"psnr": 25.218170526379815,
"ms_ssim": 0.852573794797821,
"dvh_photon": 0.0258245801119798,
"dvh_proton": 0.05720859676813071,
"mae_photon": 0.007787373382598162,
"mae_proton": 0.012321542017161846,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 96.92304203119596,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 90.31232320867716
},
{
"mae": 48.41794519874014,
"DICE": 0.8173189759254456,
"HD95": 5.526810169219971,
"psnr": 31.48434961474491,
"ms_ssim": 0.9660467998136752,
"dvh_photon": 0.04829786359957709,
"dvh_proton": 0.21069335533280592,
"mae_photon": 0.014677342027425766,
"mae_proton": 0.053213540464639664,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.73482367359013,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 76.04200239122524
},
{
"mae": 37.537562363717825,
"DICE": 0.7909422516822815,
"HD95": 5.4007134437561035,
"psnr": 33.99678981018966,
"ms_ssim": 0.9631307168906054,
"dvh_photon": 0.006360194493127837,
"dvh_proton": 0.006700073032767075,
"mae_photon": 0.003339807502925396,
"mae_proton": 0.0078020296059548855,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.99402414246444,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 94.01732940702921
},
{
"mae": 54.472540698189974,
"DICE": 0.8930928111076355,
"HD95": 2.8330750465393066,
"psnr": 31.339569053764862,
"ms_ssim": 0.9739190511169957,
"dvh_photon": 0.0016753149291020956,
"dvh_proton": 0.011774257139820846,
"mae_photon": 0.001376081840135157,
"mae_proton": 0.008340938948094845,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.44782593486549,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 92.19360878841819
},
{
"mae": 61.51169791518177,
"DICE": 0.8902363181114197,
"HD95": 3.095189332962036,
"psnr": 31.163072576671112,
"ms_ssim": 0.9764384393850778,
"dvh_photon": 0.04317121499474923,
"dvh_proton": 0.02059359546642284,
"mae_photon": 0.00692296028137207,
"mae_proton": 0.02566712163388729,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 98.40876456618986,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 77.01418323391546
},
{
"mae": 58.900902971987485,
"DICE": 0.9102896451950073,
"HD95": 2.8455302715301514,
"psnr": 30.802340362022832,
"ms_ssim": 0.9771389817732604,
"dvh_photon": 0.006119359719622526,
"dvh_proton": 0.01315447076673125,
"mae_photon": 0.003813057905063033,
"mae_proton": 0.011981381103396416,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.51778437683653,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 89.06046976511745
},
{
"mae": 65.95928445038935,
"DICE": 0.753028154373169,
"HD95": 6.034239768981934,
"psnr": 28.89497145042435,
"ms_ssim": 0.9258670845307546,
"dvh_photon": 0.0018104453287373444,
"dvh_proton": 0.134662099177862,
"mae_photon": 0.0022588951978832483,
"mae_proton": 0.009979475289583206,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 100.0,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 95.44239904988123
},
{
"mae": 58.54665816764073,
"DICE": 0.8490430116653442,
"HD95": 4.175834655761719,
"psnr": 29.93684143539172,
"ms_ssim": 0.9779485017780906,
"dvh_photon": 0.005440899279014014,
"dvh_proton": 0.5963946045649883,
"mae_photon": 0.002186607103794813,
"mae_proton": 0.008854595944285393,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.88309194545906,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 91.76284689469541
},
{
"mae": 34.606313569831066,
"DICE": 0.864800751209259,
"HD95": 2.9552717208862305,
"psnr": 36.40794624882631,
"ms_ssim": 0.9849375167950637,
"dvh_photon": 0.016782881430880265,
"dvh_proton": 0.08113192708344863,
"mae_photon": 0.009527553804218769,
"mae_proton": 0.0284438394010067,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.99660983472208,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 74.77537241993181
},
{
"mae": 36.53942890929561,
"DICE": 0.7248806953430176,
"HD95": 7.032833099365234,
"psnr": 32.4804609305376,
"ms_ssim": 0.9619455057202303,
"dvh_photon": 0.008027070418315263,
"dvh_proton": 0.021259097858600095,
"mae_photon": 0.003302762284874916,
"mae_proton": 0.008449851535260677,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.9557349303476,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 95.08798431123125
},
{
"mae": 94.78142327356849,
"DICE": 0.8175696730613708,
"HD95": 6.174675941467285,
"psnr": 25.662962343335632,
"ms_ssim": 0.9198205069421084,
"dvh_photon": 0.04559362871234046,
"dvh_proton": 0.18041082768224473,
"mae_photon": 0.010215160436928272,
"mae_proton": 0.03028407320380211,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 93.24369880943769,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 63.86179331296352
},
{
"mae": 56.527353982831904,
"DICE": 0.9174936413764954,
"HD95": 2.4128470420837402,
"psnr": 31.15097920770389,
"ms_ssim": 0.9820185580606341,
"dvh_photon": 2.0105595413001933,
"dvh_proton": 2.0189048339123477,
"mae_photon": 0.002657732693478465,
"mae_proton": 0.01093241386115551,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.58817634733587,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 88.04152525454182
},
{
"mae": 38.34742375654074,
"DICE": 0.8217822313308716,
"HD95": 3.829993724822998,
"psnr": 33.80684099937736,
"ms_ssim": 0.9800714988080633,
"dvh_photon": 0.002907686280468938,
"dvh_proton": 0.029518249805766714,
"mae_photon": 0.002645148430019617,
"mae_proton": 0.015362771227955818,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.99982995905981,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 90.72825950013038
},
{
"mae": 109.64549771639994,
"DICE": 0.42524203658103943,
"HD95": 13.480071067810059,
"psnr": 25.805161349802404,
"ms_ssim": 0.8465844142058724,
"dvh_photon": 0.08643191594752554,
"dvh_proton": 0.05984717738181904,
"mae_photon": 0.01291959173977375,
"mae_proton": 0.02732640504837036,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 94.45853471790208,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 66.42575802378109
},
{
"mae": 97.04977471751009,
"DICE": 0.7266244888305664,
"HD95": 6.900947093963623,
"psnr": 26.597125842490165,
"ms_ssim": 0.8744871955795306,
"dvh_photon": 0.022611084017197212,
"dvh_proton": 0.01752735961915691,
"mae_photon": 0.007929712533950806,
"mae_proton": 0.014586495235562325,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.9149115343117,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 89.1834108872099
},
{
"mae": 73.69127072393552,
"DICE": 0.7915207743644714,
"HD95": 4.465136528015137,
"psnr": 29.25116729416192,
"ms_ssim": 0.9261181202842295,
"dvh_photon": 0.027428269639441942,
"dvh_proton": 0.23959180024572263,
"mae_photon": 0.010581069625914097,
"mae_proton": 0.03166656941175461,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.45801157436439,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 67.982291796772
},
{
"mae": 52.18778367791803,
"DICE": 0.8838358521461487,
"HD95": 3.777777671813965,
"psnr": 32.104602047770776,
"ms_ssim": 0.9816178208156732,
"dvh_photon": 0.007410917085874259,
"dvh_proton": 0.01790941087555035,
"mae_photon": 0.0019719270057976246,
"mae_proton": 0.008398665115237236,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.8770546610663,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 90.07534164874737
},
{
"mae": 50.77872493141045,
"DICE": 0.9101757407188416,
"HD95": 2.735337257385254,
"psnr": 31.603306548689556,
"ms_ssim": 0.9764766132746956,
"dvh_photon": 0.003293583980303732,
"dvh_proton": 0.011281407235133451,
"mae_photon": 0.0019636505749076605,
"mae_proton": 0.009216273203492165,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.93435724048629,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 92.39516453526005
},
{
"mae": 57.17070063730961,
"DICE": 0.6912755370140076,
"HD95": 6.169153213500977,
"psnr": 30.54998045248815,
"ms_ssim": 0.9306387912641901,
"dvh_photon": 0.004027124568459245,
"dvh_proton": 0.6812077293881568,
"mae_photon": 0.000982683151960373,
"mae_proton": 0.012322129681706429,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 100.0,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 86.95316768988461
},
{
"mae": 60.53784816957771,
"DICE": 0.8684585094451904,
"HD95": 3.1838414669036865,
"psnr": 30.8778002963532,
"ms_ssim": 0.9562177250813451,
"dvh_photon": 0.0121606186927606,
"dvh_proton": 0.5725972489236368,
"mae_photon": 0.004860526882112026,
"mae_proton": 0.0656345933675766,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 100.0,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 64.0055743579534
},
{
"mae": 143.97631953219832,
"DICE": 0.3664146959781647,
"HD95": 7.167712211608887,
"psnr": 23.11256242922035,
"ms_ssim": 0.8333901599515857,
"dvh_photon": 0.02212017956072616,
"dvh_proton": 0.03808433202350842,
"mae_photon": 0.005129432305693626,
"mae_proton": 0.017572516575455666,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 96.22039432281755,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 80.47778740026902
},
{
"mae": 51.50572492960171,
"DICE": 0.6565461158752441,
"HD95": 7.915500164031982,
"psnr": 30.177337774701215,
"ms_ssim": 0.9341673776643928,
"dvh_photon": 0.0045558148812504555,
"dvh_proton": 0.006442967669960788,
"mae_photon": 0.0012786458246409893,
"mae_proton": 0.009298202581703663,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.73068713891404,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 96.30585977304881
},
{
"mae": 54.8412071569719,
"DICE": 0.8301467895507812,
"HD95": 5.965420246124268,
"psnr": 30.169825291111387,
"ms_ssim": 0.9583281103396483,
"dvh_photon": 0.012232281274077078,
"dvh_proton": 0.1614190753031977,
"mae_photon": 0.005512169562280178,
"mae_proton": 0.030809631571173668,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.98581362527914,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 79.14900431740263
},
{
"mae": 97.56255124272448,
"DICE": 0.7927713990211487,
"HD95": 7.531929969787598,
"psnr": 25.67809290921053,
"ms_ssim": 0.9119369474164332,
"dvh_photon": 0.016032686199151977,
"dvh_proton": 0.010106082808910441,
"mae_photon": 0.0021890534553676844,
"mae_proton": 0.004955020267516375,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.40930464790753,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 94.26030179172771
},
{
"mae": 64.38537459968718,
"DICE": 0.45444318652153015,
"HD95": 15.265131950378418,
"psnr": 28.66558046423069,
"ms_ssim": 0.8733635246534749,
"dvh_photon": 0.01685655691500712,
"dvh_proton": 0.14360972514272186,
"mae_photon": 0.010039887391030788,
"mae_proton": 0.04629864916205406,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.51221987529576,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 69.10931989924434
},
{
"mae": 71.07277424013955,
"DICE": 0.6396810412406921,
"HD95": 5.809227466583252,
"psnr": 29.43420434932242,
"ms_ssim": 0.9301460115443679,
"dvh_photon": 0.1405725597371788,
"dvh_proton": 1.133776508205941,
"mae_photon": 0.033977244049310684,
"mae_proton": 0.12955282628536224,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 94.74572968760148,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 55.694177863083816
},
{
"mae": 51.746741062661464,
"DICE": 0.9134156107902527,
"HD95": 3.114694118499756,
"psnr": 32.127716198838016,
"ms_ssim": 0.9830047907144225,
"dvh_photon": 0.0033531074519335337,
"dvh_proton": 0.02085147149025561,
"mae_photon": 0.003660045098513365,
"mae_proton": 0.017604192718863487,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 100.0,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 81.37381567614126
},
{
"mae": 54.01628144934379,
"DICE": 0.8270205855369568,
"HD95": 4.680540561676025,
"psnr": 32.17035589017754,
"ms_ssim": 0.9538803506356529,
"dvh_photon": 0.021485741050468108,
"dvh_proton": 0.07681092722725985,
"mae_photon": 0.0074537284672260284,
"mae_proton": 0.020468609407544136,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 98.52899017491833,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 83.90139772878882
},
{
"mae": 47.53593022610709,
"DICE": 0.7466952204704285,
"HD95": 7.237051486968994,
"psnr": 31.941289047700806,
"ms_ssim": 0.950386177628327,
"dvh_photon": 0.0018001767344731343,
"dvh_proton": 0.011780730254056552,
"mae_photon": 0.0025672540068626404,
"mae_proton": 0.007846004329621792,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.71892630115885,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 92.70292216821099
},
{
"mae": 54.17254987309155,
"DICE": 0.7452487349510193,
"HD95": 5.01181697845459,
"psnr": 30.1540825377173,
"ms_ssim": 0.9320603049791619,
"dvh_photon": 0.04124463380338113,
"dvh_proton": 0.03837518592347232,
"mae_photon": 0.009711606428027153,
"mae_proton": 0.022409318014979362,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 97.4232416346084,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 85.68105786170992
},
{
"mae": 63.98345028722577,
"DICE": 0.8425113558769226,
"HD95": 4.852537155151367,
"psnr": 29.509708366069233,
"ms_ssim": 0.9668201568723405,
"dvh_photon": 0.002445931716970384,
"dvh_proton": 0.01606248306395849,
"mae_photon": 0.002341916086152196,
"mae_proton": 0.009705387987196445,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.76743415603777,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 87.5928910155645
},
{
"mae": 62.83037700192685,
"DICE": 0.8763331174850464,
"HD95": 2.944444417953491,
"psnr": 29.77494902846033,
"ms_ssim": 0.9744059806809866,
"dvh_photon": 0.01897198297948104,
"dvh_proton": 0.027008060307613737,
"mae_photon": 0.0034747219178825617,
"mae_proton": 0.01051335223019123,
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": 99.84702170379578,
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": 85.27549346401814
}
],
"aggregates": {
"mae": {
"max": 146.72143000441315,
"min": 30.876109936655133,
"std": 21.961899767421,
"25pc": 54.01893042110864,
"50pc": 61.823648012412924,
"75pc": 75.88336707958914,
"mean": 67.90440684273875,
"count": 223
},
"DICE": {
"max": 0.931586742401123,
"min": 0.3664146959781647,
"std": 0.10971365317742383,
"25pc": 0.7251399755477905,
"50pc": 0.7954965233802795,
"75pc": 0.8725738227367401,
"mean": 0.7853326531536376,
"count": 223
},
"HD95": {
"max": 29.534740447998047,
"min": 2.279508590698242,
"std": 3.300550614785766,
"25pc": 3.3296984434127808,
"50pc": 4.99644660949707,
"75pc": 7.1255943775177,
"mean": 5.767158623768075,
"count": 223
},
"psnr": {
"max": 36.508098903597286,
"min": 22.98440756405885,
"std": 2.7858217724218854,
"25pc": 27.791883675126762,
"50pc": 29.964813576651636,
"75pc": 31.4121124578352,
"mean": 29.62769793981297,
"count": 223
},
"ms_ssim": {
"max": 0.985909399112442,
"min": 0.6879784035876347,
"std": 0.05261985034680232,
"25pc": 0.90595739756433,
"50pc": 0.9493321489544952,
"75pc": 0.9720755925957123,
"mean": 0.9313983655581465,
"count": 223
},
"dvh_photon": {
"max": 2.206960598527915,
"min": 0.0011375557297765028,
"std": 0.5594591156874137,
"25pc": 0.006739294163571529,
"50pc": 0.01589512022470161,
"75pc": 0.03661456903315037,
"mean": 0.19549139113667216,
"count": 223
},
"dvh_proton": {
"max": 26.630216629505643,
"min": 0.0024967060195058887,
"std": 1.8477671421899111,
"25pc": 0.02586738263000491,
"50pc": 0.07473325458579835,
"75pc": 0.2423270473789766,
"mean": 0.42664701154791423,
"count": 223
},
"mae_photon": {
"max": 0.16398677229881287,
"min": 0.0007023292127996683,
"std": 0.012126978486776352,
"25pc": 0.0025840159505605698,
"50pc": 0.0043969727121293545,
"75pc": 0.007689967751502991,
"mean": 0.006795089691877365,
"count": 223
},
"mae_proton": {
"max": 0.13422797620296478,
"min": 0.0029653620440512896,
"std": 0.019354864954948425,
"25pc": 0.010567206889390945,
"50pc": 0.015889685600996017,
"75pc": 0.028536254540085793,
"mean": 0.022792760282754898,
"count": 223
},
"gamma_pass_rate_photon": {
"max": 100.0,
"min": 32.6392619040096,
"std": 5.771280141624185,
"25pc": 98.70551337689474,
"50pc": 99.67555841692804,
"75pc": 99.98480040086,
"mean": 98.21671564178297,
"count": 223
},
"gamma_pass_rate_proton": {
"max": 98.8218905810704,
"min": 29.53034081463009,
"std": 11.540861446289343,
"25pc": 76.1191300361854,
"50pc": 85.27549346401814,
"75pc": 90.30254584610869,
"mean": 81.91701394314676,
"count": 223
}
}
}
